Press "Enter" to skip to content

Attorney slams de Blasio, Cuomo for Theatre 80 St. Mark’s plight

BY LINCOLN ANDERSON | That one of the East Village’s cultural treasures now finds itself on the ropes is a damning testament to Bill de Blasio and Andrew Cuomo’s failure to help small businesses, especially during the pandemic.

So says Village activist attorney Arthur Schwartz, who is part of the legal team fighting a predatory creditor’s attempt to sell Theatre 80 St. Mark’s out from under its current owner, Lorcan Otway.

The creditor, Maverick, was preparting to move ahead with scheduling an auction of the property, at 80 St. Mark’s Place between First and Second Avenues, for sometime in early January. But one day before a temporary restraining order blocking the sale was set to expire, Otway on Wed., Dec. 30, filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy.

Schwartz told The Village Sun the legal strategy will be to try to “undermine” the creditor’s claim.

Beyond that, he was incensed that the powers that be have allowed this situation to happen, all the while throwing massive amounts of money at, in his view, misguided priorities.

“Besides advocating for some kind of legislative fix, we plan on using the stay created by the bankruptcy filing to attack what Maverick did, and try to undermine their claim,” Schwartz said. “Time will also allow Lorcan to seek a new loan, or even a benefactor.

“What is happening here is part of the failure of de Blasio and Cuomo, who did so little to help small businesses survive the pandemic,” the attorney charged. “People can wring their hands and bemoan the loss of cultural institutions, but action is what is needed.”

Schwartz recently pushed de Blasio to the limit by representing community opponents in a lawsuit against the destructive East Side Coastal Resiliency megaproject. The attorney argued the case all the way up to the state’s highest court, the Court of Appeals, but ultimately did not prevail. However, clearly worried that he might, the city shockingly had workers going round the clock the weekend before the court case was resolved, hacking down decades-old trees and ripping up benches and pathways in the park’s southern half, trying to obliterate as much as humanly possible.

“It’s hard for me to put aside the $1.2 billion being spent on destroying East River Park, and then see how a half of one percent of that money could save this theater,” Schwartz fumed. “Local officials need to step up, and push for relief for places like this which have survived the pandemic.”

During de Blasio’s two terms in office, advocates repeatedly pushed for the Small Business Jobs Survival Act to be allowed to come up for a vote by the full City Council. A hearing was held on the bill, but Council Speaker Corey Johnson said the legislation was too broad and needed to be modified.

The other half of Otway’s legal team is a bankruptcy lawyer.

“It could be that all litigation happens through the bankruptcy court,” Schwartz noted. “So then the trustee appointed by the court is in charge. The trustee comes along with a lawyer, who looks at assets for fees [to pay off the creditor].”

Schwartz said that he had suggested the Chapter 11 strategy to Otway months ago, but that the theater owner was holding out hope of finding a benefactor.

“I pushed again recently, and he agreed,” he said.


  1. Lorcan Otway Lorcan Otway January 8, 2022

    Dear Dan Silber: We took a bridge loan, a common thing to do when a business is hit by a temporary debt. In our case, I had grown the business by 800% and then had to deal with the expenses of paying the government and estates of a deceased family member in order for this fifty-seven year old family business to survive. The taxation on the next generation of family businesses were brought in to limit the growth of families such as the Rockefellers, and did more to destroy working families than it ever did to limit the growth of the titans. Part of the loan would have increased the success I had brought to the business, growing the business, while 75 comparable theaters closed due to hyperinflation. Your predictions that we’d have gone bankrupt are made from a total lack of information or understanding of the lending industry and my business’s history. We had a year’s payments in reserve, and as one part of a complex plan, we had a company access the value of our branding at half a million dollars a year (branding theaters being a common trend today.) Cuomo was not responsible for the loan, but to shut down my business and force me into default, was in fact, the equivalent of an eminent domain taking without reimbursement. You have every right to support the “developers” turning our city from being a world cultural center to a dystopian jungle, where our city’s treasures are torn down and replaced with high-rent, featureless boxes, but you might acquaint yourself with the facts first. Finally, as Chris Hitchens put it, “On the day when everywhere looks like everywhere else, we shall all be very much impoverished, and not only that, but more impoverishingly still, we will be unable to express or even understand or depict what we have lost.”
    — Christopher Hitchens 2008. Best wishes, Lorcan

  2. Mary Reinholz Mary Reinholz January 4, 2022

    Yes, $6 mil is a big loan for which neither de Blaz nor Cuomo are responsible.

  3. Dan Silber Dan Silber January 3, 2022

    Lorcan Otway took out a loan of over $6 million that he had to pay in one year. Covid or no covid, Maverick or no Maverick, he would have been bankrupt today.

  4. Patricia Melvin Patricia Melvin January 3, 2022

    Schwartz’s analysis sounds pretty convincing, to me.

  5. Marty Curls Marty Curls January 3, 2022

    You sound like a Cheap Shot. De Blasio belongs in jail.

    Marty Curls

    • Mary Reinholz Mary Reinholz January 3, 2022

      You sound like a blank shot.

  6. Mary Reinholz Mary Reinholz January 3, 2022

    Really so weary of people bashing former Mayor de Blasio like a pinata over every problem in the city. Now Arthur Schwartz is blaming him and ex-Gov. Cuomo for Theatre 80’s financial problems. This is a cheap shot and also ludicrous.

Leave a Reply

Mission News Theme by Compete Themes.