Press "Enter" to skip to content

‘Give progressives a choice’: Gay politico urges Niou to run vs. Goldman in November

BY THE VILLAGE SUN | Dan Goldman narrowly beat Yuh-Line Niou in a crowded primary election for Congress in District 10 last week. But some feel things should not end there — and that Niou should now challenge Goldman again in the general election to give progressives “an option” on Nov. 8.

Namely, the Jim Owles Liberal Democratic Club, a citywide, progressive L.G.B.T.Q. Democratic political club led by Allen Roskoff, is urging Niou to run on the Working Families Party line versus Goldman in three months from now.

Actually, Assemblymember Niou has not yet even conceded the race to Goldman, declaring that all absentee ballots still must be counted. Nevertheless, a number of local Democratic politicians have already endorsed Goldman in the general election, including Assemblymembers Deborah Glick and Jenifer Rajkumar, Councilmember Erik Bottcher and Congressmember Ritchie Torres.

In a press release, the gay club said progresive voters in Lower Manhattan and Brooklyn deserve “an option” in District 10, and that the delayed midsummer primary election, not surprisingly, had a low turnout. (According to reports, about 12 percent of eligible voters cast ballots on Aug. 23.)

In still-unofficial results, Goldman — whom the Owles Club press release describes as “a moderate multimillionaire” — has 25.8 percent of the vote  “The candidates to his left — Yuh-Line (23.7%), Mondaire Jones (18.2%), Carlina Rivera (17%), Jo Anne Simon (6.2%) and Elizabeth Holtzman (4.4%) — won a total of 69.5% of the vote,” the club said. “This clear progressive majority needs a progressive alternative in November. We hope Yuh-Line will provide that on the WFP line and that all of her progressive rivals will unite behind her.

“There is precedent for this,” the club’s press release continued. “In 2003, the Democratic Party establishment designated the conservative Geoffrey Davis to replace his late brother in a Brooklyn City Council election. Letitia James — now our state attorney general — opposed him solely on the WFP line and won that election with 76% of the vote to Davis’s 19%.

“In 2021, when progressive India Walton won the Democratic nomination for mayor of Buffalo, the Democratic establishment — including New York State Democratic Party Chairperson Jay Jacobs — came out against their own nominee and got behind a write-in campaign for incumbent Byron Brown and prevailed 59% to 41%.

“Just as Buffalo is more conservative, the 10th Congressional District is more liberal and deserves a U.S. representative more reflective of their values,” the Owles Club’s press release asserted. “Dan Goldman — who claims to be running to ‘save democracy’ in America — can hardly complain if general election voters are given a clear choice in November when most voters go to the polls. And given that Democrats outnumber Republicans 10 to 1 in the district, there is no danger that Yuh-Line will play a spoiler role if she makes a run.”

The L.G.B.T.Q. club noted that while Goldman is “backed by a personal fortune,” Niou is “supported by an army of grassroots volunteers and small donations [and] refuses to take corporate PAC money.”

An attack mailer against Yuh-Line Niou that accused her of not being progressive because she supports saving the Elizabeth Street Garden.

In an endorsement interview in July with the Owles Club for the congressional primary, Niou — who was previously engaged to a man — answered that she was queer.

“Yes! I am a queer woman,” Niou told the club.

“The very diverse 10th Congressional District,” the club said, “also has an opportunity to add to the diversity of the U.S. Congress by electing Yuh-Line, who is a woman, an Asian American immigrant, a member of the L.G.B.T.Q. community, and would be the first openly autistic person to serve, at a time when women, Asian Americans, immigrants and L.G.B.T.Q. people are under relentless assault in this country and underrepresented in Congress. Congress must reflect the progressive diversity of our nation to be effective. If Dan Goldman truly wants to ‘save democracy’ he would acknowledge this — and he would also acknowledge that his big-money campaign was in itself anti-democratic.”

Roskoff, the president of the Owles Club, said, “We are not calling on Dan Goldman to step aside. We are calling for all progressives to stand up. We are pro-choice — an issue that Dan Goldman was weakest on during this campaign.

“We urge all Democratic political clubs and unions and other progressive groups to join a grassroots campaign to get behind the progressive alternative in the 10th District: Yuh-Line Niou,” Roskoff said. “Give progressive voters a choice.”

Niou did not respond to a question from The Village Sun asking if she is considering running on the WFP line in the Nov. 8 general election.

Roskoff did not respond to a question from the newspaper on what he thinks of Niou’s stance on Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions — a Palestinian-led movement against the Jewish state that Goldman has slammed as anti-Semitic.

Niou has played footsie with BDS in her comments to the media, saying she supports people’s free-speech right to support BDS, but that she personally does not boycott Israel.

The American Israel Public Affairs Committee’s Super PAC admitted that, during the District 10 primary race, it spent more than $400,000 on attack ads and mailers against Niou due to her position on BDS.

A Goldman spokesperson did not respond to a question asking for the candidate’s thoughts on hypothetically facing a challenge from Niou in November.


  1. Village Son of A Village Son of A August 30, 2022

    Supporting the First Amendment right to speak in support of a boycott isn’t playing “footsie” with BDS, Jesus. It’s supporting the same Bill of Rights that lets you publish The Village Sun. What is wrong with this city? Wish my fellow leftists here weren’t idiots.

    • LES3025 LES3025 August 30, 2022

      The people here are certainly not leftists.

      • WG WG August 30, 2022

        Thank you LES3025. It’s always good to know what the real estate industry thinks!

        • LES3025 LES3025 August 31, 2022

          Connie, you’re not a leftist. You’re a downwardly mobile gentrifier with no ideology other than anti-YIMBYism. Your birth announcement was in the society pages of the New York Times ( Your LinkedIn says you went to Spence. And now you write in your blog you love to link to that you don’t support expanding rent regulation (Good Cause, a leftist policy) because some people you don’t like tweeted in support of it ( Come on now.

          • fuelgrannie fuelgrannie August 31, 2022

            Good Cause must be a scam, “LES3025,” if it’s supported by the likes of Cea Weaver, Aaron Carr and Ben Carlos Thypin: As a long-term stabilized renter who seeks to expand broader rent control in New York City and beyond, I remain deeply suspicious of that proposal, Benchelle; and I’m far from the only one who has called it out.

            And define exactly what a downwardly mobile gentrifier is: I don’t own a million-dollar home, like you do, and I inherited nothing from anyone in that society page family; check out the documentary about my disabled brother and the drowning death of my mentally ill father who had died destitute but beloved (Does DMG also mean poor person? Why do you hate poor people?)

            After my father died when I was a kid, I received a partial scholarship at Spence: That detail is not on my LinkedIn.

            And, “LES3025,” I am an open book about my family’s history and my financial situation, including my current receipt of public assistance; meanwhile, you hide behind a pseudonym, angry and condescending, trying to shame me (dox me?) with facts you assume I want no one to know.

            Unlike you, I love people knowing the truth about me.

            I received no inheritance, I am a low-income earner presently on food stamps and my stabilized home has kept me housed and safe, something you seem to resent. I am part of the population you YIMBYs claim to defend.

            But, ah, your mask keeps slipping off: and we see you

  2. WG WG August 29, 2022

    I’ll vote for her. Thanks, AIPAC!

  3. savenycjobs savenycjobs August 29, 2022

    Speaking on behalf of small business owners, I hope she does not run for Congress. Instead, she should run for City Council and be the ONLY voice to stop the closings of our small businesses and save the American Dream for the entire city’s business owners and the art community. The Council is the only government in America where a new first-term lawmaker becomes the chairperson of a powerful committee that oversees Billions of dollars. In Congress a newly elected official has little power — and if the Dems are out of the majority, then no real power. The Council would be the best opportunity to a pathway to higher office, if she saved the mostly immigrant businesses. Rivera and Marte will never stand up to the real estate lobby. Save mom and pops and the arts and then run for mayor.

    • duchessofnyc duchessofnyc August 29, 2022

      Well said!

  4. John m Wetherhold John m Wetherhold August 29, 2022

    I am on board. I voted for Goldman to keep Rivera from winning.

    • JS JS August 29, 2022

      So did I. Anyone but Rivera!

    • Jan Jan August 30, 2022

      So you voted for Goldman, so you must have been OK with his potential win. But now you want a do-over.

    • Ronald J Grump Ronald J Grump September 6, 2022

      rivera did considerably worse than niou and carpetbagger. but you voted for goldman to keep rivera from winning? how did that work out for you? lol.

Leave a Reply

Mission News Theme by Compete Themes.