BY OTTO FRITTON | As electric bikes have boomed in New York City, enforcement of traffic regulations against scofflaw riders has failed to keep pace.
Many locals complain about whizzing electric Citi Bikes and other e-micro-mobility vehicles rushing pell-mell on the city’s streets and even sidewalks and sometimes traveling in the wrong direction.
John Campo is a professional cyclist and former West Point championship-winning coach. He’s also known as the “Angel of Kissena Velodrome” for pushing for a 1963 bike-racing track in Queens that had fallen into disrepair to be renovated, which the Parks Department finally did in 2004.
A cycling historian, as well, he has collected photos of early, MacGyvered, gas-powered scooters from more than 100 years ago. According to Campo, at first, such scooters were restricted to use by the disabled and limited to a top speed of 15 miles per hour. But with the advent of e-bikes that speed limit has been eased to what we see on the streets today, with e-bikes legally allowed to go up to 20 to 25 miles per hour.
Despite being a bike enthusiast, Campo is also a harsh critic of what he sees as a current lack of enforcement against e-bikes. In his view, police consistently ignore e-vehicle users who flout the rules of the road, especially, e-Citi Bikers. He’s a member of NYC E-Vehicle Safety Alliance (EVSA), the city’s leading activist group calling for greater regulation of e-vehicles.
Legislation to license and register e-bikes is pending both in the state Legislature in Albany and in the New York City Council.
“Even if they get these laws passed, they’re not going to be enforced,” Campo scoffed. “They’re still going to be riding on the sidewalk. They’re still going to be killing people.”
Campo puts the blame on police and e-cyclists alike, saying both fail to uphold their responsibilities and ensure pedestrians’ safety. He pointed to the tragic death of beloved Chinatown preschool teacher Priscilla Loke, 69, who was fatally struck by an e-Citi Bike rider at Chrystie and Grand Streets last September. Responding police initially let the cyclist leave the scene without taking down his name and contact information. Cops were eventually able to track him down later — but, as first reported by The Village Sun, he was only penalized with a slap on the wrist, a ticket for running a red light.
Meanwhile, his wife, Michele Campo, a Bowery-area quality of life activist, has advocated for anti-idling and anti-honking laws for motor vehicles, which won approval, as well as advocated for preserving local historic buildings, among other things.
“You know, my wife and I, mostly my wife, has been an advocate for community safety, for saving buildings and she has passed things for no idling, which is a $500 fine,” Campo said. “My wife has actually gone to a policeman and said this person’s been idling for half an hour. The guy said, ‘I can’t give him a ticket.’ She said, ‘Why not?’ ‘I don’t know the code,’ he said. So my wife went and got the code and brought it to the precinct, and the police captain laughed. He said, ‘I really like that’ — but still, nobody gets the tickets.”
Campo said his coaching the West Point cadets cycling team to a national championship was a personal high point — but also that the team members exemplified the integrity he sees lacking on the streets, from cyclists and police alike.
“It was just amazing,” he reflected. “I mean, they were just average kids. They weren’t really superhumans, but there was this level of integrity that I just fell in love with. When I tell them to do something, they go, ‘Yes, sir.’ There’s integrity there. When they say they’re going to do something, they actually do it.”
Meanwhile, as electric bikes continue to flourish with minimal regulations, more people — Campo included — are being hit by them. He said he was biking on the West Side greenway in the 30s when he was rammed from behind by an e-biker, leaving him with bruised ribs.
Janet Schroeder, an NYC-EVSA co-founder and steering committee member, stressed that electric bikes are not like regular bikes, but rather — due to their motors, increased weight and speed — should not be classified as bicycles but mopeds. This would require them to have a visible license plate, just like cars, that could be captured by street red-light and anti-speeding cameras, helping police identify and catch violators.
In a personal video testimony for NYC-EVSA, Campo extends an invitation to elected officials to see the issue from a civilian perspective.
“Anyone in city government, the state senator, the mayor, just ride with me on a bicycle and see what’s going on,” he says in the video. “People are making laws that have never been on a bicycle. Come out and see what’s happening out here, you know, and I wish that offer is taken up before some e-bike kills me, because biking’s my life, and I’m never gonna stop riding my bike.”
Bravo to all, especially the tireless and heroic Jack Brown, who have been fighting for common sense, sanity, and safety on our streets these many years. There has been no bicycling enforcement, accountability or environmental impact study before e-bikes were unleashed on our streets.
When will our electeds step up to address these concerns?
Thanks, Jeanie.
Adding to the various e-bike concerns and issues…..
1. Tourists – The City is proactively doing a lot of PR to encourage tourists to bicycle. So dangerous for all of us.
Tourists don’t know their way around, are trying to sightsee as they bike and often they are in a group trying to keep up with companions. On several occasions I have seen giggling tourist groups trying to access Citi Bike because it is a “thing.”
Incredibly the City does zero PR to get tourists to use the bus and subway.
There is no reason to encourage tourists to bike.
2. Teenagers – Since Covid, a noticeable surge in the numbers of teenagers using Citi Bike (mostly e-bike). Teenagers who (like adults) routinely disregard traffic rules, typically using airpods, often looking at their phones and none with helmets. And not uncommon to see teens with friends sitting in the bike’s front basket.
BTW, during the school year, it is pretty easy these days to get a student MetroCard.
Tourists and teens should be walking and taking the bus/subway.
Thank you, Mr. Fritton, for this very informative, well-researched article, and for underscoring both problems and proposed solutions to the e-bike menace. Knew about John Campo’s work to restore the Velodrome, but did not know about his cycling coach work at West Point and his advocacy work re making our streets safer. Thanks, John, for sharing those vintage motor scooter photos.
BTW: Some readers may not know that Mr. Campo is also a very fine musician.
Councilmember Carlina Rivera plans to reintroduce a bill to establish an Office of Pedestrians. This is a much-needed initiative to give pedestrians a voice to advocate for design, education and enforcement of safety in the public space. Sidewalks and crosswalks have become hostile territory for anyone trying to simply walk in New York City. We can all do better.
That’s ironic were it not so pathetic. It was Carlina Rivera — along with Margaret Chin — who pushed for the legalization of e-bikes (long illegal) back around 2016, claiming the minority delivery workers they supposedly represent (Hispanic and Chinese) needed e-bikes in order to do their jobs. As if pedal bikes like the rest of us use were not good enough. For her now to give us pedestrians this sop of an office is so typical of this hack.
I find it remarkable that people can jog marathons but can’t pedal a bike?
Thank you, John, for your work to restore sanity to our streets and sidewalks.
I second that, couldn’t have put it better myself
Carlina Rivera will say anything to give the impression she cares about her constituents while her campaign backers are her only concern.
So nice that John Campo is featured in this article for his knowledge and his activism when it comes to the ongoing problem of e-vehicles. It is truly inconceivable after all this time that the Mayor, the City Council and the NYS Assembly have ignored the crisis on NYC streets of lawless e-vehicles, mopeds and scooters. They have also ignored the thousands of NY taxpayers who have had traumatic, life-altering injuries as a result of the city allowing and, in many cases, encouraging this helter-skelter of unregulated vehicles who don’t respect traffic laws in a city of more than 8 million people.
As Jack Brown has implied, there seems to be a tacit agreement with monied lobby Transportation Alternatives, which represents the food delivery, bike-share and car-share companies, and our Mayor, Dept. of Transportation Chairperson, City Councilmembers and perhaps even the Governor to keep these vehicles unregulated. Which is precisely what Trans Alt wants. The Mayor said he doesn’t want to “encumber” the delivery people with pesky things like licensing and registration! So I guess that means they’re free to be as reckless as they wish at 25-35 mph. But they are only a part of the problem. Citi Bikes are another part and are frequently used for criminal activity.
The other part is that the NYPD does not enforce traffic laws broken by e-vehicle users. Ever!
So what are we left to do? Succumb and leave New York??
I don’t think so! Read Janet Schroeder’s comment above and join nycevsa.org. Get involved and call the Mayor’s Office and the noted councilmembers — over and over again. And if this all doesn’t work then it may be that time to acknowledge that NY is just too dangerous, and too callous and find cities that respect their citizens enough to prioritize their safety.
With previous and current administrations this city is headed in the direction of New Orleans prior to Katrina. Let’s hope and work toward avoiding a disaster to reestablish responsible and competent leadership.
You are so right. I was hit from behind with an e-bike 2 years ago. Thank god, I didn’t land on my head. Thank you, Mr. Campo. It seems that this doesn’t get to be a disaster until it happens to someone who has no idea what physical and emotional pain it brings!
We can count down the minutes until the biker bros come on here whining….”but but but … the cars…. but but but the cars…..” I applaud this man for speaking from TRUE authority on what is wrong with the rampant overtaking of our streets and sidewalks by traditional bikes, e-bikes and every manner of “micro-but-deadly-mobility-devices.” Just screaming about cars isn’t enough to distract from the dangers that THESE modes of transport pose to kids, the elderly, mobility-challenged and just normal NY’ers walking the walk. Jack Brown is 100% right.
Excellent piece. John is also a very good guitar player.
John Campo is an absolute expert on all things cycling and bike related. If you go to our web site, http://www.nycevsa.org, you will see his video testimony where he tells the story of being hit by an e-vehicle while cycling. He reveals the TRUTH about the dangers of e-vehicles, including e-Citi Bike, which have zero regulation or accountability.
What is more important than safety and health when it comes to our quality of life? The total disregard of the lives being lost and people being maimed (pedestrians, cyclists, e-bikers) on a regular basis because of this e-vehicle and moped crisis, is despicable. We must vote out politicians that do not sign onto commonsense safety bills, such as Priscilla’s Law, for registration of all e-vehicles (Intro 0606-2024). Look up your Councilmember. Have they signed? If not, call and ask them why not?
The following Manhattan CM’s have NOT SIGNED on in support of the bill:
CM Chris Marte
CM Keith Powers
CM Gale Brewer
CM Diana Ayala
CM Carlina Rivera
CM Carmen De La Rosa
Follow da money!
I think Mr. Campo’s suggestion of E-Bikes being classified as mopeds is excellent.
Greater penalties for abusers, like the person’s place of business being notified when causing an accident, besides steeper fines!
Last, Assemblyman Alex Borres (UES) has been pushing for greater E-Bike penalties.
Transportation Alternatives — the “visionaries” behind Vision Zero, aptly named — opposed enforcement by the NYPD from the time they got their hooks into the first Bloomberg administration. The sophistry being that “the more bikes on the streets the safer the streets.” No enforcement means no accountability and promotes more riding. A reckless disregard for public safety. In two and half decades the metastasis has proven to be beyond hubris and tantamount to lunacy. Meanwhile undermining the NYPD.
Charles Komanoff and Mark Gorton are the chief sophists and funders of TA. They have arm-twisted politicians and duped cult-like followers. They operate like Ivy League Trumps. Yes, Trump went to U Penn. Poor Philly.
Prof John Pucher, an internationally recognized expert and advocate for cycling, told me with regard to NO ENFORCEMENT — “I told them NOT TO DO THAT.”
VP Harris and Gov Walz are confronting the dementia that is Donald J. Trump. What politician or group is going to confront TA and the delivery apps and say, “The emperor wears no clothes — and he has been dining outdoors in the wintertime.” No candidate for mayor has made public safety a key part of their policy.
As a veteran of the bike industry I lament what has been done by cycling and micro-transport to the people in the name of righteousness.
Jack Brown
Coalition Against Rogue Riding
Yeah, Jack, I’ve known TransAlt since they started on St Marks Place. They advocated for no helmets, which make the Citi Bike not a bike at all — it is a coffin. Their own president was in a coma from biking without a helmet. We went head to head with them at City Hall and they asked us about the commuters and how they need to have a motor to get to work. It is funny how people can do marathons but can’t pedal a bike to work?? You have to scratch you head because if it walks like a snake and looks like a snake it probably is a snake. We were at City Hall on our own. They got paid to be there.
Thanks for your responsible and passionate advocacy, John.
Respectfully….
IMO, bicycles — pedal and ebike — have ruined life in NYC. Along with other micro-mobility vehicles, like stand-up scooters, skateboards, mopeds.
Bicyclists of all types ignore traffic rules and go through red lights. go the wrong way, ignore bike lanes and menace pedestrians.
Citi Bike and racing bicyclists are the most entitled, egregious and nasty, and feel free to curse any pedestrian who objects.
Adding bike lanes has wrecked the streetscape and created congestion.
Incredibly the City has implemented Open Streets on avenues, forcing buses to detour.
Bicycles also siphon from MTA bus and subway; bicyclists are not former car drivers.
Subway and bus used to be the one thing all New Yorkers shared. Now transportation is another area of stratification. And the City prioritizes and expands biking while riders of MTA bus and subway get less and less.